• Home
  • Films
  • Writing
  • Publications
  • About
Menu

S . MINDHE

  • Home
  • Films
  • Writing
  • Publications
  • About

The Reason Why

May 28, 2023

Jasper, you once asked why I chose to be a humanitarian. At the time, I gave you the answer I gave everyone. I suspected you did not believe it but did not know for sure. It has always been hard to discern your reaction to the things I say about myself. You probably knew when it comes to me, the truth is never in the first edition. It is built over the subsequent and contradictory issues.

My suspicion was confirmed when you asked the question again. But, by then, I had been repeating that same answer so many times I had no other way to respond. My answer dissatisfied me and this time I knew it dissatisfied you. Consider the below an attempt at rectifying both.

I was born in India and I left at the age of four to Australia. You know this already. What you do not know is that at six years old my parents took me back to India. The reason was for an extended stay over the Australian summer months. The trip was meant to be a homecoming. It was not.

Travelling by train, bus, and car, I saw a country of tremendous poverty on that trip. I saw life being lived on the fringes. Under bridges, between buildings, next to railway tracks. The degree and scale of impoverishment was confronting and it taught me the meaning of words that I would only learn to spell much later. Wretched. Squalor. Emaciated.

However, as lasting as those images were, sometime else made a bigger impression. It was how people looked. They looked like me. Sitting behind that bus, car, or train window, I looked at my likeness and understood the only difference between them and I was the arbitrary circumstances of birth. Behind that window, I first felt the weight of unearned privilege.

An idea took hold on that trip. I decided I needed to earn that privilege somehow. To demonstrate through action that it was not wasted on me. Finishing that trip, I only had that in mind. I guess it was a young boy’s way of dealing with all the guilt he was feeling.

It took a decade until I was reminded of that idea. At fifteen, I was researching for a history assignment. Something about the allied camps in world war 2. Scanning archival photos, I came upon James Nachtwey’s photo series covering the 1993 Sudan famine.

Stark images of the dead and emaciated stunned me and I recalled that trip to India. I looked for more photos and forgot the assignment. Gradually I learnt about the famine and the international relief workers trying to stem its impacts. I realized with rare clarity that there was a concrete way to achieve what I sought all those years ago. A way to earn the privilege I had by default.

I know phrasing it that way makes my motivation seem self-centred. I don’t disagree. To a large extent my initial motivation did come from some desire for personal redemption. A desire to rid myself of the guilt a young boy feels when he sees another young boy the same colour as him in the dirt while he speeds by in an air-conditioned car.

There was a time when this worried me. When I thought it ruined what I am doing somehow. But now I realize all that matters is that I am actually doing this. I am helping people, right now, and the concrete impact of that can’t be taken away. I think you would agree with that.

← island With No RoadsJames Foley →

Latest Posts

Featured
WhatsApp Image 2023-01-17 at 22.51.31.jpeg
January 30, 2026
Severino - 2
January 30, 2026
Read more →
January 30, 2026
2_1.jpg
January 30, 2026
Piano Notes
January 30, 2026
Read more →
January 30, 2026
WhatsApp Image 2025-01-17 at 12.10.57 PM.jpeg
January 5, 2026
Be Unreserved With The World
January 5, 2026
Read more →
January 5, 2026
PXL_20250727_155500015.jpg
November 20, 2025
Platform
November 20, 2025
Read more →
November 20, 2025
poem picture.jpg
October 1, 2024
Basics at 33
October 1, 2024
Read more →
October 1, 2024
Picture1.png
September 11, 2024
Nostalgia
September 11, 2024
Read more →
September 11, 2024
WhatsApp Image 2023-11-28 at 11.24.49 AM.jpeg
November 27, 2023
island With No Roads
November 27, 2023
Read more →
November 27, 2023
X_2.jpg
May 28, 2023
The Reason Why
May 28, 2023
Read more →
May 28, 2023
WhatsApp Image 2023-04-27 at 10.35.57 PM.jpeg
April 27, 2023
James Foley
April 27, 2023
Read more →
April 27, 2023
WhatsApp Image 2023-04-22 at 15.10.00.jpeg
April 22, 2023
Shimmer
April 22, 2023
Read more →
April 22, 2023
WhatsApp Image 2023-04-11 at 10.05.54.jpeg
April 10, 2023
Decision To Leave
April 10, 2023
Read more →
April 10, 2023
WhatsApp Image 2023-04-09 at 22.48.32.jpeg
April 8, 2023
Gap In The Breakers
April 8, 2023
Read more →
April 8, 2023
WhatsApp Image 2023-02-23 at 1.02.18 PM.jpeg
February 22, 2023
Severino - 1
February 22, 2023
Read more →
February 22, 2023
WhatsApp Image 2023-01-04 at 10.09.02.jpeg
January 3, 2023
The Next Moment
January 3, 2023
Read more →
January 3, 2023
Picture_SydneyReturn_V2.jpg
January 22, 2022
Sydney Return
January 22, 2022
Read more →
January 22, 2022
Picture_GoatTrails_v1.jpg
November 26, 2021
Goat Trails
November 26, 2021
Read more →
November 26, 2021
Picture_BackseatView_v2.jpg
November 26, 2021
Backseat View
November 26, 2021
Read more →
November 26, 2021
P1000279.JPG
November 24, 2021
The Boy's Gaze
November 24, 2021
Read more →
November 24, 2021